We had a customer recently inquire as to whether the authentication channel between a client and a SQL Server was encrypted by default. While we know that SSL is supported on SQL Server 2005, we did not have a certificate installed. However, it was rumored that the system would use a self-signed certificate. Also, we wanted to explore the differences between SQL Server 2000 and SQL Server 2005, as well as the differences between different providers.
I searched for documentation confirming that the authentication channel was indeed encrypted and was able to come up with the following from this MSDN article: http://msdn2.microsoft.com/en-us/library/ms189067.aspx
“Microsoft SQL Server 2005 can use Secure Sockets Layer (SSL) to encrypt data that is transmitted across a network between an instance of SQL Server and a client application. The SSL encryption is performed within the protocol layer and is available to all SQL Server clients except DB Library and MDAC 2.53 clients.”
“Credentials (in the login packet) that are transmitted when a client application connects to SQL Server 2005 are always encrypted. SQL Server will use a certificate from a trusted certification authority if available. If a trusted certificate is not installed, SQL Server will generate a self-signed certificate when the instance is started, and use the self-signed certificate to encrypt the credentials. This self-signed certificate helps increase security but it does not provide protection against identity spoofing by the server. If the self-signed certificate is used, and the value of the ForceEncryption option is set to Yes, all data transmitted across a network between SQL Server and the client application will be encrypted using the self-signed certificate.”
Well, this contradicted some posts I had read but did point us in the right direction. So, we decided to test this. I setup two Virtual Machines, one running a .NET web application and a .NET windows application, and one running SQL Server 2005 Express Edition. I then installed Network Monitor 3.1 and captured the traffic on the NIC as we tested the connection using the SQL Native Client (SQLNCLI) and OLEDB (System.Data.SqlClient).
We saw the server send a self-signed certificate to the client and after which, the authentication channel was encrypted. We also ran the same test on SQL Server 2000. While the authentication channel is not encrypted with SQL Server 2000, the password is not sent in clear text. Rather, it appears obfuscated – most likely using an offset of some kind. We did see the username come across in clear text.
To summarize, when using SQL Server 2005, the authentication channel is completely encrypted when using any clients except DB Library and MDAC 2.53 clients regardless of whether the server has a SSL certificate installed.